At the “Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geosciences and Geoenergies” ETH Zurich studies, in close collaboration with national and international partners, techniques and procedures for a safe, efficient, and long-term use of geothermal heat. A focus lies on the physics of induced seismicity. Researchers conduct different experiments. Whereas some put a strong emphasis on the geothermal processes involved, others test different drilling and stimulation techniques. A dense monitoring system allows to observe even the smallest changes in stress, pressure, and fluid movements. Only in a rock laboratory, such close monitoring is possible and affordable.
Many insights into the creation of geothermal reservoirs were gained from the Bedretto Reservoir Project. This project was a kind of initial project for the BedrettoLab. It encompassed three sub-projects with complementary targets for the development of a large-scale deep reservoir for the circulation of water and the storage and extraction of geothermal energy. One of these projects was VALTER, in which a proxy of a geothermal reservoir was created.
The VALTER experiment (Validating of Technologies for Reservoir Engineering), funded by the Swiss Federal Office of Energy, tested in unprecedented detail on a realistic scale of several hundred metres innovative technologies and processes to create a commercially viable underground heat exchanger while minimising the risk of major earthquakes. The project has now been completed.
The comprehensive knowledge gained will be crucial for subsequent projects:
The largest project currently underway is the FEAR project (2022 – 2028). FEAR stands for "Fault Activation and Earthquake Rupture" and focuses on gaining an understanding on how earthquakes start and stop.
At the end of April 2024, a first longer stimulation project was carried out as part of FEAR. Therefore, water was injected under pressure into the injection borehole over several days with the aim of triggering a magnitude 0 earthquake. This experiment was successful and an earthquake with a small deviation of magnitude 0 was triggered
Currently, a new side tunnel is being built for this project. It will be used to monitor a fault zone from a very close distance.
The first stage of tunnel excavation will start in summer 2024, after which the tunnel construction (drill-and-blast method) will be interrupted to investigate the effects of the blasting in the surrounding rock (PRECODE project: "Progressive Excavation Damage Zone Evolution During And Post Mine-By Tunnelling").
The FEAR project is funded by a Synergy Grant from the European Research Council (ERC).
A project funded by the SFOE (Swiss Federal Office of Energy) (BEACH - Bedretto Energy Storage and Circulation of Geothermal Energy), which is running since November 2023, is investigating the extent to which granitic rock could serve as a heat storage system. Such storage could help to bridge energy shortfalls that exist when renewable energies (solar or wind energy) are scarce. In the experimental phase of the project, warm water will be injected into the existing reservoir in order to circulate it and then withdraw it again later.
In a real-life rollout, this warm water could then either be used to supply district heating or converted into electricity.
The BEACH project experiments will start at the end of 2024.
We hope to gain a better understanding of the relevant processes in the framework of a deep geothermal exploration. Our results aim at contributing to a safer and more sustainable use of geothermal energy in Switzerland and elsewhere. This is a precondition for being able to increase the share of geothermal energy by five to ten percent, needed to fulfil the goals set in the Energy Strategy 2050.
The “Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geosciences and Geoenergies” itself will not generate any heat or electricity for commercial use, but one experiment will create a geothermal reservoir, which will be used to test heat exchange on a monthly and yearly basis.
The BEACH project further explores the potential for heat storage in cristalline rock.
Related to geothermal research is the earthquake physics research. In the framework of the FEAR project, we conduct research to better understand fundamental processes leading to an earthquake and putting it to a halt.
Please have a look at the following page: Activities.
Experiments & Safety
Very small, not perceptible earthquakes are an inherent part of deep geothermal projects. They cause fractures and keep them open, both enhancing the permeability of a reservoir necessary for an efficient operation. The aim of every geothermal project is to enhance the permeability without causing any felt or damaging earthquakes. In some cases, they also cause felt or damaging earthquakes even though the aim of every geothermal project is to enhance the permeability without causing such events.
At the “Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geosciences and Geoenergies”, very small earthquakes are as well expected. Compared to natural, damaging earthquakes, the size of the volume stimulated and the depth of the rock volume are considerably smaller. Therefore, the risk of provoking perceptible or even damaging earthquakes is extremely low. A dense monitoring system allows us to observe even smallest seismic activity.
Before an experiment is carried out, the potential risk is evaluated in advance and the experiment is designed to mitigate potential risks. During the experiment, a so-called traffic light system, which evaluates real-time data, supports the extent to which an experiment must be adjusted immediately or stopped if a previously defined magnitude threshold is exceeded.
Our aim is to investigate how we can prevent noticeable or damaging earthquakes and not how we can cause them in the BedrettoLab.
Environment
There are no environmental risks since we do not inject any chemicals, nor will any other harmful substances be used.
Work safety
A rock laboratory including the handling of different instruments, heavy equipment and tools naturally offers a less safe working environment than a regular office. Therefore, different measures are taken to protect the technicians and researchers working at BedrettoLab. In addition to mandatory protective clothing, work processes are defined in advance and monitored as far as possible.
Occupational safety is inspected at regular intervals by an external body, as is the condition of the tunnel in terms of changes to the walls and ceilings and potential risk of rock fall.
The Bedretto tunnel, connecting the Ticino with the Furka tunnel, offers ideal conditions to perform these experiments. It allows to pursue the research conducted in laboratories at universities and in other rock laboratories, e.g. at Grimsel, on a bigger scale.
This is an important advancement to prove previous concepts in a setting reflecting as closely as possible the conditions in the deep underground. The coverage of 1,000 to 1,500 meters above the tunnel simulates well the pressure conditions at relevant depths for a geothermal reservoir.
In order to operate such a rock laboratory, the tunnel has undergone extensive construction work: the floor was levelled out and unstable rocks were secured; a ventilation system, a communication network, and electricity were installed. The owner Matterhorn-Gotthard-Bahn has currently leased the tunnel to ETH Zurich for eight years.
Similar experiments have already been conducted on smaller scales at university laboratories or at the Grimsel rock laboratory. The ”Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geosciences and Geoenergies” now offers the opportunity for experiments on a bigger scale, which allows verifying previous results in a more realistic setting. Instead of stimulating rock formations at a couple of centimetres as in a laboratory, or at a scale of 10 meters as in Grimsel, experiments will be conducted on a scale of 100 meters and more. Therewith, the rock formation stimulated is still smaller than in a real deep commercial geothermal project, but significantly bigger than what has scientifically been analysed so far. In addition, the coverage of 1,000 to 1,500 meters above the tunnel simulates well the pressure conditions at relevant depths for a geothermal reservoir.
Deep geothermal energy accesses rock structures at least 400 meters into the earth, and various uses are possible depending on the temperatures in the subsoil.
Temperatures of between 20 °C and 70 °C are found in aquifers (layers of rock or soil that can absorb and hold water) at depths of 400 to 2,000 meters. The thermal water found at these depths is suitable not only for bathing but also for heat production, and systems that exploit the drainage water from tunnels can be put to a similar use (SFOE, Nutzung der Erdwärme - Überblick, Technologie, Visionen).
At depths of 4,000 meters, temperatures beneath Switzerland are between 150 °C and 200 °C. Geothermal energy projects that access these layers of rock generally use part of the energy recovered directly for power production, while the rest can be fed into a district heating grid.
A distinction is made between two systems for energy recovery at great depth: petrothermal and hydrothermal. For further information visit: www.seismo.ethz.ch/en/knowledge/things-to-know/geothermal-energy-earthquakes/forms-of-geothermal-energy/.
We facilitate visits for the following groups upon request and according to our capacities:
Please contact Stefanie Zeller (stefanie.zeller@sed.ethz.ch) for further information.
There are no more public tours scheduled for the rest of this year (2024). Public tours will be held again in 2025, led by guides from the Museum Sasso San Gottardo.
Dates will be announced in spring 2025 on our website. Tickets will be available for purchase through Museum Sasso San Gottardo.
More infos about the tours can be found here: https://www.bedrettolab.ethz.ch/en/about/visit/